MIntheGap posted something today that has helped me identify part of my problem. He writes about two errors that many Christians make today as highlighted by Scott Buchanan in his article Indifferentism vs. Everythingism: Stay in the Middle of the Road.
First, let’s get some definitions out of the way:
- Indifferentism is the error of accepting the gospel but refusing to acknowledge the doctrines of the gospel as “unbreachable boundaries for Christian faith and fellowship.”
- Everythingism is the error of holding all doctrines on the same level as the gospel, making every belief a boundary for faith and fellowship.
The problem here is that both are wrong Scripturally. The one is wrong because there are doctrines that go along with salvation that must be maintained. The other is wrong because not every doctrine is of the same weight as salvation or necessary for salvation.
I fall into the second category. Well, I’m desperately trying to get out of that second category. To the point of wearing nothing but red shirts.
Most Christians tend to be more sensitive to one error and to neglect the other. Many evangelicals are quick to perceive the intrinsic factiousness of everythingism, but in avoiding it they become tolerant of indifferentists. Fundamentalists go miles out of their way to avoid the compromise of indifferentists, but they are willing to put up with the everythingists. On both sides, political considerations sometimes become more important than integrity.
If we want a truly biblical Christianity, then we are going to have to avoid both errors. We are going to have to treat everythingists and indifferentists with about the same misgiving. Of course, in order to do that we shall have to become skilled at judging the importance of doctrines. We must develop special proficiency for discriminating fundamentals from non-fundamentals.
As much as I hate labels, I like being able to identify an issue that I’m having.
I asked a friend last week how you go about changing something that’s been engrained in you for so long and his answer, annoying as it was, is true: “You just…do.” That’s my current goal. To change. To be able to take my faith seriously despite my doubts. To trust God even when I don’t trust myself.
Don’t expect it to happen overnight.






